the long and short of it

So on the nights that we just stay at home and watch tv, this is what I do:)

 I crochet. It's not knitting. I use a hook, not needles. It's fun. You should really try it. 

Ever since I saw this thick chunky yarn, I have wanted to make a cowl. But I wasn't sure if I like long cowls or short cowls:)

 

So I made one of each... What do you think? Long?

 

or short?